Liberty Unbound
by Don Crawford
"For seven decades A.A. has been a natural laboratory for how civil
society can operate effectively without government authority. I've
been surprised, therefore, to have seen A.A. mentioned only once in
libertarian publications. It was in a rant that appeared some years
ago in Liberty, complaining about the apparent collusion between A.A.
and the judicial system: courts have sentenced people to attend A.A.
meetings, thereby enriching the organization. Having seen the
phenomenon of court-ordered attendance at A.A. meetings from the
inside, I found the rant deliciously ironic. People in trouble for
drunk driving are commonly assigned to attend some number of meetings,
over a period of time. The judge gives them a 'court card' to get
signed at each meeting they attend, and they return the completed card
as proof that they were there. The courts have a variety of
inducements, such as avoiding jail, to make sure that these cards are
returned completed. So here's the irony. There is nobody in charge at
A.A. No one ever signed a contract (who would be authorized to sign
it?) and agreed to do this service for the courts. In fact, there are
some folks in A.A. who don't think they should sign the cards -- and
this made for some interesting exchanges, like the following." (08/09)