Interesting talk with a Public Defender's office attorney

Last night at a party I met a guy who works at the Public Defender's
office who told me some really interesting stuff, which I'm going to
try to get him to send me in more detail in writing. Some of the things
he mentioned:

-While the D.A.'s office is having trouble managing their caseload
(good!), the Public Defender's office is now well-staffed, thanks to
Jeff Adachi. Apparently Jeff went to the Board of Supervisors and told
them that he didn't have the personnel to handle all the cases, and
consequently they were going to pull back from taking cases generated
by certain departments at the Hall of Justice. Because people have a
constitutional right to free legal representation, these cases would
instead go to contracted lawyers who would be a lot more expensive for
the city. Therefore by giving us more staff, you'll save money, he
said. This logic persuaded the board to fund 15 extra positions. My
source has a high opinion of Adachi (as do I), and says that the office
functions in a very non-hierarchical way, with senior attorneys willing
to ask junior attorneys for help in areas they're less experienced with
and so on. He says Adachi has promoted the ethic of treating poor
clients exactly as if they had paid a lot of money to be represented in
the private sector.

-In domestic violence cases, "the cops probably charge the wrong person
80 percent of the time" in his opinion. With heterosexual couples, they
normally charge the man, whether he's most at fault or not. He said one
person pushing the other in a marital dispute shouldn't rise to the
level of the criminal justice system. Most of the time the victims do
not want to press serious charges, and often they come to him to find
out what will happen to their partners or spouses, even though he
represents the accused and is forthright about telling them this. This
is largely how he's discovered that...'s in the D.A.'s office routinely lie to victims in order
to secure their testimony. (This may not exactly be news, but it's
still nice to hear it confirmed by an official source.) He said they
sometimes threaten people with jail if they don't testify, even when
they would have no legal ability to imprison someone. He also said they
have told domestic abuse victims that they just needed their testimony
in order for their abuser to get counseling, when in fact the actual
consequences for the accused would be more serious, such as jail time.

-The Sheriff's Department, which manages the county jail, has routinely
been refusing to let defendants out of jail in order to attend
restraining order hearings. However if someone shows up at the jail
with papers to serve someone, they *will* serve them! Judges apparently
have been unaware of this; they simply see that a defendant failed to
show up for a hearing. Since they can see on the paperwork that the
person was properly served, they typically rule against them. My source
says he had been doing other types of cases, but had started doing
domestic violence, and was furious with the Sheriff's Department when
they would not release his client from jail to attend his hearing. When
he brought the matter up in court, it turned out the judge had no idea
this was happening either, and the judge hit the roof too. My source
was unaware of any press coverage of this, but agreed the matter should
be exposed and expressed a willingness to name names.

-He knew very little about the Community Court system -- something I
myself learned about only in the past year or so and have previously
posted about on this list. He agreed that having a police officer stay
in the room with the panelists determining a person's sentence while
the person had to leave the room was "fucked up," and is interested in
learning more about how the community courts works. He said he's never
yet had a client who was transferred to community court come back and
pursue justice through the regular courts.

Yours in liberty,
        <<< Starchild >>>

------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor --------------------~-->
Make a clean sweep of pop-up ads. Yahoo! Companion Toolbar.
Now with Pop-Up Blocker. Get it for free!

Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to: