# FW: Proposition J Doesn't Work

**URL:** <https://forum.lpsf.org/t/fw-proposition-j-doesnt-work/2177>\
**Category:** Discussion\
**Created:** [February 4, 2004, 1:48am UTC](https://forum.lpsf.org/t/fw-proposition-j-doesnt-work/2177 "2004-02-04T01:48:44Z")\
**Posts on this page:** 1\
**Page:** 1

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![sarosh5312](https://forum.lpsf.org/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/s/5f8ce5/32.png) [@sarosh5312](https://forum.lpsf.org/u/sarosh5312)\
**Post date:** [February 4, 2004, 1:48am UTC](https://forum.lpsf.org/t/fw-proposition-j-doesnt-work/2177/1 "2004-02-04T01:48:44Z")

</div>

In a message dated 2/3/2004 5:03:14 PM Pacific Standard Time,  
robpower@... writes:  
Ever since RBASF teamed up with Gonzalez to prop up their corrupt exploitation  
of existing codes requirements, I really don't want to be their ally on  
ANYTHING. But I also don't like the idea of taxpayers subsidizing new  
buildings. Frankly, if Prop J just did away with the environmental studies,  
I'd be for it, but the subsidy sounds like too much. I suppose one could make  
the argument that, with as much as we tax property owners in SF, the subsidy  
will not even let them break even in the long run. So I'm borderline "in  
favor" / "no position" on J. But I certainly don't want to back RBASF.  
Hi Rob, Mike,

I am commenting in response to your request to shed some light on the  
backstory on Prop J.

RBA is against ANY other developer getting permits to build ANY housing in  
SF. They managed to get the lions share of permits for many years, and all the  
builders in their group paid their "toll" to RBA honcho O'D. He parceled the  
money out to politicians and spent it on ballot measures to solidify his control  
over housing policy, to perpetuate scarcity on the "for-profit" side.

Calvin Welch, Randy Shaw and their cabal of non-profits control housing on  
the "government subsidy" side. They have worked closely with RBA at all times to  
make sure the personnel at DPW, the administrative rules, and the substantive  
decisions all worked to maintain that hegemony. Together, they have  
controlled housing policy, limited production, and kept prices and profits high. Theirs  
has been a marriage of convenience, fueled by their greed and mutual  
self-interest in limiting housing in SF.

Now there is an effort to break that stranglehold. Further, by building  
ownership housing, the proportion of renters vs homeowners will change (very  
slightly). But RBA and the nonprofits are reluctant to let even a single unit be  
built without them getting their "mordida".

Prop J does away with some of the procedures that have been used to make  
getting permits such a nightmare for anyone who was not "connected" with either  
RBA or the nonprofits. Many "neighborhood organisations" are typically front  
organistions whose members dont really understand how they are being manipulated.  
The leaders of these organisations sometimetimes do understand, but have  
their own axe to grind, such as getting publicity, a role in the neighborhood, or  
even financial incentives or a political career. Its not pretty.

Its more than OK that some developers not connected with RBA are allowed to  
make a profit in SF. If development did not require such a lengthy and  
byzantine process of approval from every city department and neighborhood group,  
housing policy would be a lot more sane and straightforward. The zoning on a piece  
if land is only a first approximate step in determining what can be built  
there. The reason that permit expediters like Walter Wong and O'D are  
millionaires, is because the building permit system is a black box which the bad guys  
control. Its not a coincidence that they supported Gonzalez, Chris Daly et al.  
They help each other, to the ordinary citizen's detriment.

RBA's O'Donoghue is a master at orchestrating barriers that prevent  
construction of housing. We should not let him get away with it. He does not mention  
how RBA got special legislation sponsored by Chris Daly to get a density bonus  
at their new project at Fourth and Freelon, South of Market. RBA will reap an  
estimated additional revenue of $ 70-80 million for the 100+ extra units they  
were allowed to build. That construction is going on RIGHT NOW. In return for  
the non-profits cooperation, RBA agreed to build and GIVE to Tenderloin Housing  
Clinic a brand new building worth approximately $ 20 million, on which THC  
boss Randy Shaw will collect government subsidy rents in perpetuity. Can you  
trust ANYTHING that RBA is connected with? I think the answer is a resounding NO.

Break RBA's monopoly! Yes on Prop J!
