# Frankness About Wealth Redistribution

**URL:** <https://forum.lpsf.org/t/frankness-about-wealth-redistribution/15468>\
**Category:** Discussion\
**Created:** [September 27, 2012, 8:48pm UTC](https://forum.lpsf.org/t/frankness-about-wealth-redistribution/15468 "2012-09-27T20:48:32Z")\
**Posts on this page:** 1\
**Page:** 1

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![ortegan](https://forum.lpsf.org/letter_avatar_proxy/v4/letter/o/57b2e6/32.png) [@ortegan](https://forum.lpsf.org/u/ortegan)\
**Post date:** [September 27, 2012, 8:48pm UTC](https://forum.lpsf.org/t/frankness-about-wealth-redistribution/15468/1 "2012-09-27T20:48:32Z")

</div>

[http://www.thedailybell.com/4360/Tibor-Machan-Frankness-About-Wealth-Redistribution](http://www.thedailybell.com/4360/Tibor-Machan-Frankness-About-Wealth-Redistribution)

Frankness About Wealth Redistribution  
Thursday, September 27, 2012 – by Tibor Machan

Dr. Tibor Machan

When taxation is part of government, wealth  
redistribution goes hand in hand with it. Taxation was what feudal  
systems used so as to pay rent to the monarchy. The monarch, after all, used to own the realm. All of it. So just as owners of apartment  
houses, monarch's collect rent from those living in there.

The meaning of this is that members of the population got to live in  
the country by permission of the government, be that a tzar, king,  
pharaoh, caesar or some other ruler who had nearly absolute power to run the place. It is still so in many regions of the globe. The people  
aren't deemed to have rights, including private property rights. That  
emerged late in the history of Western politics, mainly within the  
philosophy of the Englishman John Locke and his followers. They defended the idea of natural rights against those who championed the divine right of monarchs.

With the American Revolution the Lockean system started to be implemented, though by no means fully. This abolished serfdom or involuntary servitude but didn't quite  
manage to abolish taxation, namely, the confiscation of people's  
resources, although in principle that should have followed the  
revolutionary turn of events. If citizens own their lives − have an  
unalienable right to life −they also own the fruits of their labor.  
(And such fruits did not need to be created by them from scratch as Mr. Obama suggested with his misguided remark, "You did not build that.")

In any case, when governments confiscate resources from the people  
via taxation, the sort of wealth redistribution that Mr. Obama and other statists are avidly defending cannot be avoided. Taking their wealth  
and handing it out to some citizens for various purposes simply involves redistributing that wealth, period, be it justified or not.

Government's redistribution of the citizens' wealth is unavoidable  
unless taxation is abolished. Even the most minimal of taxation brings  
about such redistribution.

But in systems of limited government such as what the United States  
of America was supposed to become, the wealth redistribution was  
supposed to be minimal! That is where Mitt Romney is basically correct while Mr. Obama is wrong. It is under collectivist kinds of statism, in which the wealth of a country is deemed to be  
owned by the government exactly as Mr. Obama and those who support his  
political philosophy see it, that citizens do not have the right to  
private property but merely get to dispose of some property that the  
government allows them to retain from their earnings and findings.  
(Yes, Virginia, some private property is found, meaning it isn't built  
from scratch but arises from good fortune, like the wealth one gains  
from one's talents or good looks!) But just because one doesn't build  
one's wealth it doesn't follow that government owns it. That is rank  
non sequitur. (After all, one doesn't build one's pretty face or good  
health either, yet it doesn't belong to Mr. Obama!)

The real issue is whether the wealth one owns is to be distributed by oneself or others! Extensive taxation assumes that it may be  
distributed and redistributed by others, specifically by the government − politicians and bureaucrats. Not only that, but that these latter  
actually own one's wealth, including one's labor just as is believed  
under socialism wherein all the major means of production, including human labor, is  
collectively owned and administered − distributed and redistributed − by government officials. (Several major American political theorists, like Thomas Nagel and Cass Sunstein, argue for exactly that idea.)

This is the issue that could be debated in the current presidential  
campaign. Who is to do the distribution and redistribution, the  
citizenry or the state? In a free society it is the former that gets to do the bulk of the distribution and redistribution as it spends funds  
in the marketplace, gives some away, etc. In a welfare state, and  
especially in the full-blown socialist society, it is government, with  
the people left "permitted" to make some decisions about the allocation  
of resources.

Which is it to be in America? Why and how? That is what could be  
fruitfully debated now! But instead, the campaign is bogged down in  
moronic trivia and detail. It should be dealing with the fundamentals of the nature of free government − at least a substantially free  
government!

No. The Democrats refuse to admit that they really favor the  
socialist alternative, basically; and the Republicans lack the  
philosophical savvy to stand up for a truly free system of government,  
wherein the latter is seriously limited in its powers.
